So I bought a few pair from Zappos:
Then I saw a fantastic Cyber Monday sale on Willits saddles in black and white, so bought them:
Willits have been making saddle shoes for years and have many widths to choose from. The white stands up to hard wear better than I'd have thought, and having been married to an Army guy I know how to shine shoes!
The Fedora Lounge has so much info on saddle shoes, I could never have figured this out in an evening without their resources. Thanks ladies!